Home of Chicago's Finest Oven-baked Sandwich
All sandwiches include your choice of apple, potato chips, pretzels or Sun Chips.
Add a small side and a drink to any sandwich for only 2.75
Costello Icons
Spicy Roscoe - $6.59
Pepper turkey, capicola and pepper jack cheese on a sub roll with pepper rings, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo & classic vinaigrette.The Mess - $6.69
Genoa salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, french fries & cole slaw (yes, on the sandwich!) and tomato all on a sub roll.Village Veggie - $6.59
Provolone & muenster cheeses with hummus baked on multi-grain bread, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumbers, & black olives.
Costello Club - $6.79
Our triple decker! Piled high with smoked turkey, tavern ham, jalapeño bacon, muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato & garlic mayo on multi grain bread.Subpocalypse - $6.89
Our 2011 Sandwich Challenge winner! Ciabatta sub roll topped with smoked turkey, ham, capicola, jalapeno bacon, cheddar, pepper jack , lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings and chipotle ranch.Southern Reuben - $6.59
Turkey pastrami with Swiss cheese on rye, baked (not grilled) topped with homemade slaw & thousand island dressing.
Grinders - $6.49
Italian
Genoa salami, capicola, ham and provolone on a sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.Turkey Provolone
Roasted turkey and provolone on a sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, garlic mayo, and classic vinaigrette.
All Veggie
We start with a whole-wheat sub roll top it with hummus and provolone dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, and classic vinaigrette.Tuna Salad
Our homemade parmesan tuna salad on a sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, and classic vinaigrette.
The Birds - $6.49
Smokin' Turk
Smoked turkey breast and cheddar on an Italian sub roll topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings and mayo.Pepper Turkey
Pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese baked on an Italian sub roll with with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings and chipotle mayo.
Chipotle Chicken
Grilled chicken strips & pepper jack cheese baked on a sub roll with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings and chipotle mayo.Turkey Lite
Roasted turkey breast baked on a whole wheat roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, low-fat chipotle mayo and low-fat Italian dressing.
Classics - $6.59
Horseradish Beef
Roast beef and provolone cheese, on our muffuletta bread, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions and our own horseradish sauce.Italian Meatball
Delicious meatballs covered with rich marinara sauce and provolone cheese, baked on a hoagie roll.
Beefsteak
Tender roast beef au jus, provolone cheese, with sauteed onions and peppers, baked on a hoagie roll, topped with our roasted garlic mayo.Tavern Ham & Swiss
Tavern ham on our muffuletta bread with melted swiss cheese, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo and deli mustard.
Focaccia - $6.59
Roast Turkey
Roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.Pesto Chicken
Tender chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, classic vinaigrette, parmesan and provolone cheeses, topped with creamy pesto.
Veggie Pizza Pie
Our focaccia topped with marinara, black olives, red pepper, red onion and provolone cheese.- "Our locally produced Focaccia is seasoned with Italian herbs and bits of roasted tomato."
Wraps - $6.49
Monterey Chicken
Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack baked in a chipotle tortilla wrap with pico de gallo, lettuce and chipotle mayo.Southwest Veggie
Pepper jack cheese, fresh pico de gallo, red bell pepper, black olives, lettuce and chipotle mayo baked in our southwest tortilla.
Parmesan Tuna
Our homemade tuna salad wrapped up with lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, and classic vinaigrette.Turkey & Muenster
Roasted turkey, muenster cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pepper rings and olives with chipotle mayo in a tomato basil tortilla.
Salads - $6.99
Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken strips, crisp romaine lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, tangy Caesar dressing tossed with finely grated parmesan.Antipasto
Romaine lettuce, black olives and pepper rings tossed with classic Italian dressing, topped with capicola, genoa salami, ham, and provolone.
Southwest Chicken
Grilled chicken strips with black bean-corn relish, tomato, red pepper, romaine lettuce, cheddar cheese and chipotle ranch dressing.Garden
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red peppers, red onions, black olives, your choice of cheese, and our classic vinaigrette.
Sides - Small $2.99, Medium $5.49, Large $9.99
Soups, Chili and more
- Cold sides
- Red pepper rotini
- Mustard potato salad
- Pineapple tuna with shells
- Hot Sides
- Chipotle mac 'n' cheese
- Red skin mashed potatoes
- Creamy cole slaw
- Northwoods chili - Small $2.99, Medium $5.39, Large $9.99
- Soup of the Day - Small $2.99, Medium $5.49, Large $9.99
- Chili Mac - Small $2.99, Medium $5.39, Large $9.99
- Hummus Cukes and Pita - $3.99
- Garlic Cheese Bread 2.99
- Pizza Bread $3.99
Kid's Menu $4.00
Desserts + Beverages
- Kid's Sandwich - Baked American cheese, PB & J, turkey & cheese, ham & cheese or Cheese pizza boat.
- Kid's Side - Pretzels, Goldfish, Apple sauce, Jello cup, Potato chips or Animal crackers.
- Cookie and small drink
- Cookies - $2 and and Are you kidding!
- rice krispy treats for 75 cents?
- Beverages - Fountain $1.50, Bottle $2