Chicago Sandwich & Sides Costello Sandwich & Sides - Home Chicago Sandwich & Sides Costello Sandwich & Sides -  Menu Chicago Sandwich & Sides Costello Sandwich & Sides -  Catering Chicago Sandwich & Sides Costello Sandwich & Sides -  History Chicago Sandwich & Sides Costello Sandwich & Sides -  Contact Chicago Sandwich & Sides
 
 
Three Ways to Order
 

The Don Costello
Turkey pastrain & genoa salami baked on an Italian sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and our new and zesty Costello pepper relish.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Beefsteak Grinder
Juicy and tender roast beef au jus baked on our Italian Sub roll with sauteed peppers, onions and provolone cheese, topped with our special roasted garlic mayo.
Sandwich $6.94    Costello Combo $8.23    Deluxe Meal $9.24

Italian Grinder
Genoa salami, Capicola, ham and provolone cheese baked on an Italian sub dressed with tomato, lettuce, onion, pepper rings, classic vinaigrette and roasted garlic mayo.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Spicy Roscoe
Hot capicola, pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese on an Italian sub with pepper rings, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo and classic vinaigrette.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

The Mess
Genoa salami, Capicola, ham, provolone cheese, French fries (yes, ON the sandwich), cole slaw (yes, on again), and tomato, all sandwiched on a sub roll. A meal in one... try it!
Sandwich $6.94    Costello Combo $8.23    Deluxe Meal $9.24

Monterrey Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken strips & pepper jack cheese—baked in a chipotle tortilla wrap with pico de gallo, lettuce & chipotle mayo.
Sandwich $6.94    Costello Combo $8.23    Deluxe Meal $9.24

Chipotle Chicken
Grilled chicken strips & pepper jack cheese—baked on a sub roll with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings & chipotle mayo.
Sandwich $6.94    Costello Combo $8.23    Deluxe Meal $9.24

Meatball Sliders
A mini-meatball sandwich served on a soft little square bun with sautéed onions, cheese and roasted garlic mayo. Unbelievably tasty! You get two sandwiches per order.
Sandwich $5.88    Costello Combo $7.18    Deluxe Meal $8.18

Tuna Grinder
Homemade parmesan tuna salad baked on a sub roll and topped with lettuce, tomato, pepper-rings, onions and classic vinaigrette.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

 

Smokin' Turk
Smoked turkey breast and cheddar cheese baked on an Italian sub topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, & mayo.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Pepper Turkey
Pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese baked on an Italian sub with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings and chipotle mayo.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Turkey Wrap
Roasted turkey, meunster cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pepper rings and olives with chipotle mayo wrapped in a tomato basil tortilla.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Turkey Foccacia
Roasted turkey baked on tomato foccacia bread, lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.
Sandwich $6.94    Costello Combo $8.23    Deluxe Meal $9.24

Horseradish Roast Beef
Roast beef and provolone cheese-baked on our Muffuleta bread. Dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions, and house-made horseradish sauce.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Southern Reuben
Turkey pastrami and swiss cheese baked (not grilled) on rye, topped with homemade coleslaw and Thousand Island dressing
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Italian Meatball
Delicious meatballs in an Italian sub covered with marinara sauce and provolone cheese.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Heartland
Roast beef, ham, turkey breast and Swiss cheese baked on our hearty multi-grain bread, topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Classic Ham & Cheese
Premium smoked ham—baked on our white Muffuleta bread with melted provolone cheese. Dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, and classic vinaigrette.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Vegetarian

Village Vegetarian
Provolone, muenster and hummus, baked on multi-grain bread, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, sprouts and black olives.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.78

The Pizza Pie
Tomato foccacia bread oven baked with marinara & black olives under melted provolone cheese—dressed with sliced tomato and house recipe pepper relish. Add salami for $1.25
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68     Deluxe Meal $8.68

 

Southwestern Veggie Wrap
Pepper jack cheese, fresh pico de gallo, red bell pepper, black olives, lettuce, & chipotle pepper mayo baked in our southwest chipotle tortilla.
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

Baked is Better PB & J
Creamy peanut butter and blackberry jelly—baked on our scrumptious Italian sub roll—simple and soothing.
Sandwich $5.09    Costello Combo $6.39    Deluxe Meal $7.39

Healthy Choices

Turkey Lite
Roasted turkey—baked on a whole wheat sub roll—dressed with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, low-fat chipotle mayo and low-fat Italian vinaigrette—Low fat—but delicious!
Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

 

Make any sandwich lower in fat, calories, or carbs by substituting the dressings or bread with these ingredients:

Low-fat mayo, low-fat chipotle mayo, low-fat garlic mayo, low-fat mustard-mayo dressing, low-fat Italian, yellow or brown mustard, Low-fat pepper-relish, lower-carb tortilla wraps.

 
Make Your Own

Create your perfect sandwich!

Sandwich $6.38    Costello Combo $7.68    Deluxe Meal $8.68

 
Bread
Italian sub
(white or wheat),
rye,
multi-grain,
tomato basil
tortilla,
Muffuleta bread,
chipotle tortilla,
tomato foccacia
(foccacia 75¢ extra)
  Meat
Genoa salami,
hot capicola,
smoked turkey,
pepper turkey,
roast beef, ham,
roasted turkey,
parmesan tuna
salad, turkey
pastrami,
grilled chicken strips
(strips 50¢ extra)
(choose one)
  Cheese
Provolone,
cheddar,
Swiss,
muenster,
pepper jack,
american
(choose one)
  Toppings
Onion,
tomato,
lettuce,
pepper rings,
black olives,
sprouts
Costello
Pepper relish
(relish 50¢ extra)
(choose as
many as you like)
  Dressings
Mayonnaise, yellow
or brown mustard,
classic vinaigrette,
roasted garlic-mayo,
chipotle pepper mayo,
low-fat mayo,
low-fat chipotle mayo,
low-fat italian,
fat free honey dijon,
horseradish sauce,
low-fat garlic mayo
Salads

Dressing choices: Classic Vinaigrette, Ranch, Thousand Island, low-fat Vinaigrette, Fat Free Honey Dijon

Costello House Salad
Mixed field greens, fresh tomato, cucumber, black olives, and red bell pepper topped with provolone. Classic vinaigrette on side.
$5.36

Italian Salad
Mixed salad greens, fresh tomato, cucumber, black olives and red bell peppers topped with Genoa salami, smoked ham, hot capicola & provolone. Served with house classic vinaigrette on side.
$6.94

 

Grilled Chicken Salad
Mixed salad greens, fresh tomato, cucumber, and red bell pepper topped with provolone cheese and grilled chicken strips. Choice of dressing on the side.
$6.94

Southwest Chicken Salad
Tender chicken strips, cheddar cheese, fresh red pepper and our tomato-corn salsa over a bed of field greens and romaine lettuce.
$6.99

Appetizers

Garlic Bread
$1.78
with provolone - $2.78
cup of marinara for dipping - 75¢ extra

 

Home - Made Hummus
Served with Southwest chipotle tortilla.
Regular $1.99
Large $3.99

Costello Side, Soups and Chili xz

Small $1.54     Medium $2.04     Big $3.74     Family $6.54

Red Skin mash
Red skinned potatoes mashed with garlic, sour cream, and butter (skins and all, chunky style).

Red Pepper Pasta Salad
Rotini pasta tossed with fresh red and green bell peppers, celery, cucumber, and a sweet and tangy dressing.

Mustard-Mayo Potato Salad
Made fresh daily with eggs and just the right mix of mustard and mayo.

Chipotle Mac & Cheese
A spicy hot mac & cheese made with chipotle peppers and rotini pasta.

Creamy Cole Slaw
Old Fashioned Style—In a creamy celery dressing.

 

Grandma Costello Pasta Marinara
Great as a meal or with any sandwich.

Maryanne's Pineapple Tuna Salad
Shell pasta, tuna and juicy pineapple chunks mixed in a mayo dressing. Served chilled (a family holiday favorite!)

Pasta Aglio Olio
Rotini pasta tossed with tasty sauce made from olive oil, garlic, butter and parmesan cheese.

Costello's homemade Soup Always fresh, delicious and hot!
Cup $2.24, Bowl $2.99, Big Bowl $4.34

Costello's homemade Chili Always fresh, delicious and hot!
Cup $2.59, Bowl $3.34, Big Bowl $4.89

Kids Menu

Kids Menu (8 years and under)

Kids sandwiches use a "crustless" wheat bread and include one kids side, small drink and cookie. $3.25

Kids Sandwiches: (Choose one)
Peanut Butter & Jelly, Cheese Pizza Boat, Baked American Cheese

 

Kids Sides: (Choose one)
Potato Chips, Pretzels, Jello Cup, Animal Crackers, Gold Fish, Apple Sauce (Sugar Free)

Dessert
Shakes
Regular $2.49
Large $2.89
chocolate, vanilla, strawberry
make it a malt for 30¢
add Oreos or M&Ms for 75¢
  Soft Serve Ice Cream
(Lincoln Square location only)
Ice Cream Cones $1.50
chocolate, vanilla, swirl
add sprinkles for 30¢
Sprecher Root Beer Float $3.00
  Cookies & Treats
Chocolate Chip Cookies 50¢
Krispy Rice Treats 50¢

We also carry a variety of seasonal cookies and sweets.
 

Extras

Add a wallop of flavor to any sandwich with our house relish made from assorted peppers and fresh vegetables

Extra Cheese...$1
Extra Meat...$1.25
Sweet Peppers...50¢
Cucumbers...30¢
Hot Gardinera...50¢
Cup of Marinara...75¢
Pico De Gallo...75¢
Bag of Chips or pretzels...89¢
Costello Pepper Relish...50¢

 

Beverages

Regular $1.49
Jumbo $1.79

Coca-cola Classic, Diet Coke, Sprite, Barq's Root Beer, Nestea Sweetened Iced Tea, Minute Maid Lemonade

Sprecher Root Beer & Cream Soda $1.75,
Nantucket Nectars $1.75, Bottled Water $1.50
Hot Chocolate $1.25, Tea $1.25, Gatorade $1.75

Premium Dark Roast Coffee only $1.49